name: sh:business-panel
description: "Multi-expert business analysis with advisory recommendations (no scoring gate)"

/sh:business-panel — Business Panel Analysis

Usage

/sh:business-panel [document_path_or_content] [--mode discussion|debate|socratic] [--focus competitive|growth|risk|communication] [--experts "name1,name2"] [--synthesis-only]

Behavioral Flow

1. Load Panel Config: Read experts/panels/business-panel.yaml for panel definition, focus areas, and auto-select rules
2. Load Experts: Read expert files from experts/individuals/ for each selected expert — these contain domain, methodology, and critique focus
3. Auto-Select Experts: Scan content against panel YAML auto-select keywords — add matching experts up to max-experts: 6 cap
4. Analyze: Parse business content, identify strategic themes and domains
5. Assemble Panel: Select experts based on --focus area or use default-experts. --experts override replaces defaults entirely
6. Conduct Analysis: Run analysis in the selected mode using each expert's distinct framework
7. Synthesize: Generate consolidated findings with consensus, disagreements, and prioritized recommendations

No scoring gate — this is an advisory panel. It produces strategic analysis and recommendations only.

Expert Panel (9 experts from core-business pack)

Analysis Modes

Discussion Mode (--mode discussion)

Collaborative analysis where experts build upon each other's insights through their frameworks. Default mode. Sequential commentary, cross-expert validation, consensus building.

Debate Mode (--mode debate)

Adversarial analysis for stress-testing ideas. Experts challenge each other's positions, surface disagreements, and argue alternatives. Use for controversial topics or high-stakes decisions.

Socratic Mode (--mode socratic)

Question-driven exploration for deep strategic thinking. Experts pose probing questions rather than giving answers. Forces deeper examination of assumptions and alternatives.

Focus Areas

• competitive: Competitive positioning, market forces, strategy. Lead: Michael Porter. Experts: Porter, Christensen, Kim & Mauborgne
• growth: Marketing, tribe building, scaling. Lead: Seth Godin. Experts: Godin, Collins, Drucker
• risk: Risk management, antifragility, systems dynamics. Lead: Nassim Taleb. Experts: Taleb, Meadows
• communication: Structured clarity, presentation, stakeholder messaging. Lead: Jean-luc Doumont. Experts: Doumont, Godin

Output

Business analysis document containing:
- Expert perspectives from selected panelists
- Consensus points across experts
- Disagreements with reasoning from each side
- Priority-ranked strategic recommendations
- Actionable next steps

SYNTHESIS ONLY — this panel produces expert analysis and recommendations. It does not implement any business recommendations, make code changes, or execute decisions without explicit user approval.